516-987-8296

Custom Cookies for Any Occasion

How it works!

Call Mama's Custom Cookies at 516-987-8296

Discuss options, schedule an appointment & secure your delivery date.

Sit Down with a Designer

Work together with an artist to come up with the perfect design for your occasion.

Receive Delivery or Pick-up Your Cookies

Pick-up your cookies or we will ship them to your destination!

We Ship Anywhere You'd Like

Send a gift to your Mom or order Corporate Sales Treats in bulk, these cookies will be sure to put a smile on the face of even the most discerning recipient!

Mama’s Custom Chocolate Chip Cookies

Spring is finally showing up here on the East Coast, and while we soak in the longer days of sun and the warmth on our skin, the nights still hold the chill of the previous season that has left us. This brings light comfort food to mind. When the evening gets darker...

April Showers Bring Spring Cookies…

Have you noticed that April showers of snow are not stopping May flowers intent on popping through our half-frozen earth? That means Spring is in the air! And Spring cookies... Soon the world will be budding with abundance and here at Mama’s Custom Cookies that means...

All Things New at Mama’s Custom Cookies!

Opening a new cookie shop on Long Island is a much bigger undertaking than one might imagine! My life has become a series of inspections, construction obstacles, and picking out colors, styles, textures. New content for this website didn’t materialize out of thin air...

Hi there! It’s me, “Mama.” Many of you may know me as Rosemarie DeMaio, owner, operator and art designer of Mama’s Custom Cookies.

Turning cookies into art has been my passion since 2012 when a friend and I stumbled upon the idea while thinking up unique gift ideas for guests. We both agreed that delicious custom cookies would be the perfect way to do to show how much we care. After that first batch, I knew that this was meant for me.

I can’t think of a better way to express my creativity than by designing artful treats for any of your special occasions — Who doesn’t delight in beautiful, yummy cookies?

Plus, it’s the ultimate combination of all of my favorite things: art, individuality, sweets and making people smile.

I hope you enjoy my cookies as much as I enjoy creating them.

Rosemarie