WHO WE WORK WITH
MEET MAMA
Many of you may know me as Rosemarie DeMaio, owner, operator and CCCD (Chief Custom Cookie Designer) of Mama’s Custom Cookies. Turning cookies into art has been my passion since 2012 when a friend asked about creating “different” favors for an event she was hosting. We both agreed that custom cookies would be the perfect gift/favor. We envisioned the cookies being the final touch/design to compliment the event.
I hope you enjoy our cookies as much as we enjoy creating them for you.
- Rosemarie
Work with a Designer
Work with an artist to come up with the perfect design for your occasion.
Pick-Up OR SHIPPED TO YOUR DOOR
Pick-up your cookies or we will ship them to your destination!
They Love
OUR COOKIES
The cutest fire truck cookies for my son's 4th birthday! Customer service was great and the whole process was super simple. Highly recommend!
Angela
Mama's is the onlyyyy place I go when I need a gift of any kind. Whether for a family member or a high profile client...these are thoughtful, delicious and gorgeous.
Jamie
I recently ordered cookies for my baby shower and they were perfect! They were made well, they were delicious and professionally packed (no broken or chipped cookies).
Also, they were quick with responding to my questions….I wanted a different color so I reached out and I received a response within hours.
Great cookies and customer service!! Highly recommend!
Ivee
Mama's Custom Cookies created some of the most beautiful, intricate Earth Day cookies for the business I work for to send out to some of our community partners. There were 8 total orders shipped to different addresses and each of them was received before/on the anticipated date and the customer service was very lovely. I would absolutely recommend their business to anyone looking for custom cookies!
Melanie
Follow Us on The Gram
Contact Us
(516) 670-2768
3335A Park Avenue
Wantagh, NY 11793
Store Hours By Appointment Only
Mama's Custom Cookies © 2025
